Wednesday, 16 December 2009

s e s s i o n t e n - D O S P A S S O S


Further to previous sessions regarding the tradegy of 'modern development' we encounter the three stories of Henry Ford (Tin Lizzy), The Architect (Frank Lloyd Wright) and Thorstein Veblen (The Bitter Drink). These contribute to the account of American Society in the early part of the 20th Century and its demise of the social order - in the tradegy of 'modern' development. These so called mini biographies with the addition of the newsreels and 'camera eye' create a depiction of the undefined period in American, where with so much prospect and principles were deviating from the Great American Dream.


The Story of Veblen, the bitter drink, gives the account of an individual who did not want to contribute to this modern society. He did not want to conform to its rules of engagement and almost parallels Brian Rourke's honest ideals (session nine - fountainhead). He refused to work against his will, to teach what others wanted him to teach, act in a manner which pleased others . Instead he opted to live, work and comply with his own agenda and his principles, ideals in which served him and not served society.
However in conjunction with last weeks session, this honest and truthful approach cannot be feasible within the realms of this society. Although there are times one can chose such righteous paths, many decisions are made based on the rules of the machine, and such virtuous decisions are impossible.

Thursday, 3 December 2009

s e s s i o n n i n e - F O U N T A I N H E A D


Howard Roark was a dreamer, a creationist, a developer. He strived to create an honest architecture, an urban utopia free from traditional connotations, historical suggestions, and nostalgic association with past architectural principles. His vigor and intensity of uncompromising his “truthful” ideals, confronting the pressures within society and resisting the tendencies of architecture of that epoch is very relieving and pleasant to watch, ascertaining that in the end honesty and truthfulness prevails.

Brian, sincere as he is, refuses to tolerate the conformists within society, spearheaded by the Banner manifesto, similar to the present day manipulation of the media, stands up for what he believes in and chooses to struggle in obscurity rather than compromise his ideals.

However realistically, today, this honesty is not plausible as we have to conform to planners, clients, authorities [the machine] conforming to historical topographies, contextualizing, (which refers to the building next door) reducing the architectural merit in order to enable the old lady next door to see past our apparent “monstrosity” Unfortunately we are the Peter Keating and not the Mr. Roark.

The film seems to be based on Frank Lloyd Wright due to the resemblance to its architectural connection, but similarly it could resemble Mies and Corbusier just as much. These characters all shared the same motivation and dynamism as Brian Roark, all tried to create an honest and progressive architecture free from unessential historical motifs, and an architecture that follows the function.

s e s s i o n e i g h t - THE TRADEGY OF DEVELOPMENT


Marshall Berman’s the tragedy of the development refers to the story of Goethe’s Faust. It is subdivided into three sections; The Dreamer, The Lover and the Developer each being a metaphorical comparison between Faust and modernity.

Goethe’s Faust, according to Berman, is one of the protagonists of “modernity”, and as mentioned, he is a “consummate, wrecker and creator” and hence he is the first “modern” developer. Faust was a visionary, “a dreamer”, striving to create his “perfect” society, a utopia for the benefit of humanity through forced economic development on a grand scale. It was with this vision, that induced destruction by means of creation and many innocent lives were ruined as well as enriched, albeit he agonized over the costs of modernization to those who opposed.

The Gretchen tragedy in my opinion epitomizes the scenario in which society is based upon, Gretchen referencing the innocent people, Faust, the developer and the little world with traditional ideals in which he attempts to develop. I believe that this is the dilemma in which modernity spawns, the creation off- springing from destruction, the “modernism of the underdeveloped”, and hence in Gretchen’s case you either adapt to the change (in society) or perish, The latter being the result in the story of Faust.

Furthermore it is my belief that the bourgeoisie cannot exist without constantly revolutionizing society and its means of production, and for progression to take place, which I believe to be essential, the Gretchen of society, [un]fortunately have to adapt to accommodate the change.